Choose from 18 Wire Colors

black cross nails keychain
Black cross nails keychain

Choose a small cross keychain in one of 18 solid wire colors. Each keychain with a cross includes a sturdy key ring and is handmade from genuine horseshoe nails. Select classic silver, a gold cross keychain, or another favorite color for $5.20 each. Order 25 or more crosses from our site to receive free shipping.

Each keychain is made by hand. The unique colors stand out from ordinary accessories, making this keychain not only practical but also a genuine conversation starter and a thoughtful gift for friends, family, or yourself.

Explore More Small Cross Keychains

Show your faith! Share your story!

Choose from 18 different colors.

Take the Small Keychain Cross Made with Nails with you everywhere, and let it be a symbol of strength and connection each day.

This is the baby blue cross color.

Baby Blue


This is the black cross color.

Black


This is the brown cross color.

Brown


This is the burgandy cross color.

Burgandy


This is the - cross color.

Copper


This is the gold cross color.

Gold


This is the green cross color.

Green


This is the lavender cross color.

Lavender


This is the magenta cross color.

Magenta


This is the navy cross color.

Navy


This is the orange cross color.

Orange


This is the pink cross color.

Light Pink


This is the purple cross color.

Purple


This is the red cross color.

Red


This is the silver cross color.

Reg. Silver


This is the shiny cross color.

Shiny


This is the teal cross color.

Teal


This is the white cross color.

White


HORSESHOE NAIL CROSS

Handcrafted From Genuine Horseshoe Nails In Kentucky • Since 2004.

Free Shipping on orders of 25 or More Nail Crosses.

© 2026 Horseshoe Nail Cross. All Rights Reserved.

All USA Sourced Materials